← All stories

Slideshow · Entertainment

10 Famous Movie Roles Almost Played by Robert De Niro

As a two-time Academy Award winner and screen legend, Robert De Niro turned down or almost starred in some of Hollywood's biggest hits. Here are ten roles Robert De Niro almost played.

27 Oct 2026

4 Min Read11 Slides
  1. A split cover comparison of The Godfather and Big.
▼ Visual Countdown

As a two-time Academy Award winner and screen legend, Robert De Niro turned down or almost starred in some of Hollywood's biggest hits. Here are ten roles Robert De Niro almost played.

Swipe or tap ▶ to begin the countdown

©TMDb / Paramount Pictures & TMDb / 20th Century Fox

📖 Complete Countdown Guide

All 10 Entries in this Story

10 Highlights · Full Editorial Review
#1

10. Sonny Corleone In The Godfather

Robert De Niro auditioned for hot-tempered Sonny Corleone, giving a ferocious screen test that impressed Francis Ford Coppola. Coppola cast James Caan, saving De Niro to play young Vito in Part II.

10 Famous Movie Roles Almost Played by Robert De Niro — Sonny Corleone In The Godfather
Photo: TMDb / Paramount Pictures
#2

9. Josh Baskin In Big

Penny Marshall originally cast Robert De Niro as the boy who turns into a man in Big, offering $6 million. When De Niro encountered scheduling delays, Tom Hanks stepped in and earned an Oscar nod.

10 Famous Movie Roles Almost Played by Robert De Niro — Josh Baskin In Big
Photo: TMDb / 20th Century Fox
#3

8. Bill The Butcher In Gangs Of New York

Scorsese developed Gangs of New York for decades with De Niro attached to star as nativist leader Bill 'The Butcher' Cutting. By 2000, De Niro stepped aside and Daniel Day-Lewis stepped in.

10 Famous Movie Roles Almost Played by Robert De Niro — Bill The Butcher In Gangs Of New York
Photo: TMDb / Miramax Films
#4

7. Hannibal Lecter In The Silence Of The Lambs

Director Jonathan Demme approached Robert De Niro to play the brilliant cannibalistic psychiatrist Dr. Hannibal Lecter. De Niro passed on the script, allowing Anthony Hopkins to win an Oscar in 16 minutes.

10 Famous Movie Roles Almost Played by Robert De Niro — Hannibal Lecter In The Silence Of The Lambs
Photo: TMDb / Orion Pictures
#5

6. Harry Lyme In Home Alone

Director Chris Columbus offered the role of bumbling burglar Harry Lyme in Home Alone to Robert De Niro. De Niro declined, prompting Columbus to cast De Niro's frequent co-star Joe Pesci.

10 Famous Movie Roles Almost Played by Robert De Niro — Harry Lyme In Home Alone
Photo: TMDb / 20th Century Fox
#6

5. Dick Tracy In Dick Tracy

During pre-production for the stylized 1990 comic strip adaptation Dick Tracy, Warren Beatty offered De Niro the title role before deciding to direct and star in the project himself.

10 Famous Movie Roles Almost Played by Robert De Niro — Dick Tracy In Dick Tracy
Photo: TMDb / Touchstone Pictures
#7

4. Captain Queenan In The Departed

Martin Scorsese offered his longtime muse Robert De Niro his choice of playing police captain Oliver Queenan or mob boss Frank Costello in The Departed. De Niro passed to direct The Good Shepherd.

10 Famous Movie Roles Almost Played by Robert De Niro — Captain Queenan In The Departed
Photo: TMDb / Warner Bros. Pictures
#8

3. Paul Sheldon In Misery

Director Rob Reiner offered the role of bedridden romance novelist Paul Sheldon to Robert De Niro. De Niro declined due to the physically passive nature of the character, passing the role to James Caan.

10 Famous Movie Roles Almost Played by Robert De Niro — Paul Sheldon In Misery
Photo: TMDb / Columbia Pictures
#9

2. Captain Willard In Apocalypse Now

Francis Ford Coppola offered Robert De Niro the starring role of Captain Willard in Apocalypse Now. De Niro declined to spend five grueling months in the Philippines, opting to prepare for The Deer Hunter.

10 Famous Movie Roles Almost Played by Robert De Niro — Captain Willard In Apocalypse Now
Photo: TMDb / United Artists & Omni Zoetrope
#10

1. Jimmy Conway In Goodfellas

Robert De Niro's commitment to play seasoned Irish-American gangster Jimmy 'The Gent' Conway gave Martin Scorsese the green light from Warner Bros. to produce the definitive mob masterpiece.

10 Famous Movie Roles Almost Played by Robert De Niro — Jimmy Conway In Goodfellas
Photo: TMDb / Warner Bros. Pictures

Up Next · Recommended Stories

6 stories