← All stories

Slideshow · Entertainment

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked

Ranked according to critical consensus scores from Rotten Tomatoes and the American Film Institute, these 20 detective masterworks redefined mystery cinema. Ranked according to critical scores from Rotten Tomatoes and American Film Institute archives, these 20 brilliant detective movies kept audiences guessing until the final frames.

4 hours ago

8 Min Read21 Slides
  1. The Most Acclaimed Detective and Whodunit Masterpieces in Cinema History
▼ Visual Countdown

Ranked according to critical scores from Rotten Tomatoes and American Film Institute archives, these 20 brilliant detective movies kept audiences guessing until the final frames.

Swipe or tap ▶ to begin the countdown

©TMDb / L.A. Confidential & TMDb / Paramount Pictures

📖 Complete Countdown Guide

All 20 Entries in this Story

20 Highlights · Full Editorial Review
#1

20. Brick (2005)

Teenagers spoke in sharp hardboiled noir slang. Joseph Gordon-Levitt starred as an isolated high school sleuth investigating his ex-girlfriend's sudden murder. Johnson filmed the entire indie feature on a modest five hundred thousand dollar budget.

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked — Brick (2005)
Photo: TMDb / Leonine Studios
#2

19. Kiss Kiss Bang Bang (2005)

Unlikely partners drove this frantic Hollywood murder mystery. Robert Downey Jr. played an accidental actor paired with Val Kilmer's sharp private investigator. The clever neo-noir script helped launch Downey's major career resurgence.

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked — Kiss Kiss Bang Bang (2005)
Photo: TMDb / Kiss Kiss (Bang Bang)
#3

18. The Nice Guys (2016)

Physical comedy elevated the gritty private eye work. Gosling's bumbling investigator teamed with Crowe's ruthless enforcer to expose deep automotive corruption across smoggy 1970s Los Angeles. It remains an enduring cult favorite.

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked — The Nice Guys (2016)
Photo: TMDb / Silver Pictures
#4

17. Who Framed Roger Rabbit (1988)

Detective Eddie Valiant walked dangerous cartoon streets. Bob Hoskins gave an earnest performance as a traumatized private eye investigating murder in post-war Los Angeles. Groundbreaking optical effects earned four Academy Awards.

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked — Who Framed Roger Rabbit (1988)
Photo: Wikimedia / movieposterdb.com; rotated by 270°
#5

16. The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo (2011)

Cold family secrets unravel across an isolated Swedish island. Daniel Craig's journalist teamed with Rooney Mara's brilliant hacker to solve an unsolved disappearance from forty years prior. Trent Reznor's score amplified the dread.

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked — The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo (2011)
Photo: TMDb / The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo
#6

15. Gosford Park (2001)

Julian Fellowes penned an intricate country estate whodunit. When their wealthy host is murdered during a hunting weekend, aristocratic social facades crumble in front of the servants. The film won Best Original Screenplay.

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked — Gosford Park (2001)
Photo: TMDb / Sandcastle 5
#7

14. Prisoners (2013)

Moral boundaries collapse in freezing Pennsylvania rain. Jake Gyllenhaal played Detective Loki, obsessively deciphering cryptic clues while an anguished father conducts his own brutal interrogation. Roger Deakins captured gorgeous cinematography.

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked — Prisoners (2013)
Photo: TMDb / Alcon Entertainment
#8

13. Shutter Island (2010)

Paranoia mounts with every coastal storm. Leonardo DiCaprio portrayed a US Marshal investigating an impossible patient disappearance from a remote asylum for the criminally insane. Layered psychological twists deceive audiences completely.

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked — Shutter Island (2010)
Photo: TMDb / Paramount Pictures
#9

12. The Fugitive (1993)

Wrongful murder accusations triggered an electric nationwide manhunt. Tommy Lee Jones won an Academy Award portraying relentless Marshal Samuel Gerard while Harrison Ford tracked down the true killer. The film earned seven Oscar nominations.

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked — The Fugitive (1993)
Photo: TMDb / Warner Bros. Pictures
#10

11. Mystic River (2003)

Neighborhood grief destroyed lifelong childhood friendships. Kevin Bacon played a state detective investigating a teenager's murder while suspicion fell upon their emotionally shattered companion. Sean Penn and Tim Robbins earned Oscars.

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked — Mystic River (2003)
Photo: TMDb / Warner Bros. Pictures
#11

10. Knives Out (2019)

Greedy family heirs squabbled over an eccentric mystery author's estate. Daniel Craig debuted as Southern sleuth Benoit Blanc, unraveling family deceptions with Ana de Armas. Box office receipts exceeded three hundred million dollars.

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked — Knives Out (2019)
Photo: TMDb / MRC
#12

9. The Big Sleep (1946)

Atmospheric menace triumphed over straight narrative logic. Bogart traded electric dialogue with Lauren Bacall while navigating an intricate web of blackmailers in post-war Los Angeles. It remains the gold standard of noir style.

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked — The Big Sleep (1946)
Photo: Wikimedia / Warner Bros.
#13

8. The Third Man (1949)

Zither melodies echoed through post-war Vienna rubble. Joseph Cotten played an American pulp author investigating his friend's suspicious death, leading to Orson Welles' unforgettable entrance. The film defined shadow-drenched noir.

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked — The Third Man (1949)
Photo: TMDb / London Films Productions
#14

7. Memento (2000)

Severe anterograde amnesia shaped this intricate narrative structure. Guy Pearce relied on Polaroid photos and body tattoos to track clues while being manipulated by strangers. Nolan's breakthrough earned an Oscar nomination.

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked — Memento (2000)
Photo: TMDb / Newmarket Films
#15

6. Fargo (1996)

Midwestern decency prevailed against pathetic criminal greed. Pregnant Police Chief Marge Gunderson solved a horrific roadside homicide through patient investigative routine. Frances McDormand won Best Actress for her work.

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked — Fargo (1996)
Photo: TMDb / PolyGram Filmed Entertainment
#16

5. Vertigo (1958)

San Francisco served as a hypnotic backdrop for psychological obsession. James Stewart portrayed an acrophobic detective hired to track a wealthy friend's haunted wife. Sight and Sound voted it among the greatest films ever made.

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked — Vertigo (1958)
Photo: TMDb / Paramount Pictures
#17

4. Zodiac (2007)

Obsessive detail drove this landmark investigative procedural. Jake Gyllenhaal and Mark Ruffalo portrayed real-life investigators chasing cryptic ciphers across decades of unresolved murders. Fincher followed police evidence fanatically.

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked — Zodiac (2007)
Photo: TMDb / Paramount Pictures
#18

3. L.A. Confidential (1997)

Three contrasting detectives tackled a brutal coffee shop massacre. Russell Crowe, Guy Pearce, and Kevin Spacey clashed over justice and police brutality in 1950s Los Angeles. The film won two Academy Awards.

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked — L.A. Confidential (1997)
Photo: TMDb / L.A. Confidential
#19

2. The Maltese Falcon (1941)

Greed swirled around a priceless statuette. Bogart outsmarted a ring of eccentric European criminals without violating his personal code of honor. Huston's directorial debut established modern American detective cinema.

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked — The Maltese Falcon (1941)
Photo: Wikimedia / Warner Bros.
#20

1. Chinatown (1974)

Water rights and civic corruption poisoned 1930s Southern California. Jack Nicholson delivered his signature performance as private eye J.J. Gittes, discovering horrifying municipal conspiracies. It remains the American Film Institute's top-ranked mystery.

20 Best Detective and Whodunit Movies Ever Made, Ranked — Chinatown (1974)
Photo: TMDb / Paramount Pictures

Up Next · Recommended Stories

6 stories