← All stories

Slideshow · Entertainment

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants

It is a rare phenomenon in Hollywood when critical consensus is completely ignored by the moviegoing public. From slashers to supernatural thrillers, these 22 horror films were panned by critics but became massive commercial successes, proving that sometimes, audiences just want a good scare regardless of the

28 min ago

9 Min Read23 Slides
  1. Critics loathed them, but audiences flocked to theaters
▼ Visual Countdown

It is a rare phenomenon in Hollywood when critical consensus is completely ignored by the moviegoing public. It is a rare phenomenon in Hollywood when critical consensus is completely ignored by the moviegoing public.

Swipe or tap ▶ to begin the countdown

©TMDb / Platinum Dunes & TMDb / New Line Cinema

📖 Complete Countdown Guide

All 22 Entries in this Story

22 Highlights · Full Editorial Review
#1

1. Scary Movie

Perhaps the ultimate example of a critical failure becoming a blockbuster success, 'Scary Movie' was savaged by reviewers but became a massive pop culture hit that defined an entire era of comedy-horror.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — Scary Movie
Photo: Wikimedia / Dam0812
#2

2. Cloverfield

The found-footage monster movie received mixed critical feedback due to its shaky-cam style. Regardless, the buzz surrounding its mysterious marketing made it an unmissable cinematic experience for audiences.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — Cloverfield
Photo: TMDb / Bad Robot
#3

3. The Purge

The first 'Purge' movie was dismissed by many critics for failing to realize its full premise. Yet, it captured the public imagination so effectively that it became the start of a massive horror universe.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — The Purge
Photo: TMDb / Universal Pictures
#4

4. Saw 3D: The Final Chapter

Critics felt the 'Saw' franchise had long run out of ideas by its seventh installment. However, the promise of a finale brought in curious and dedicated fans, yielding another solid financial result.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — Saw 3D: The Final Chapter
Photo: TMDb / Twisted Pictures
#5

5. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003)

This remake took a serious approach to the original's gritty roots. While critics found it unnecessary, the marketing campaign and the power of the original title drove audiences to theaters.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003)
Photo: Wikimedia / New Line Cinema
#6

6. A Nightmare On Elm Street (2010)

Critics felt this remake lacked the imagination of the 1984 original. Despite this, the sheer weight of the Freddy Krueger brand name generated substantial interest and ticket sales.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — A Nightmare On Elm Street (2010)
Photo: TMDb / A Nightmare on Elm Street
#7

7. Friday The 13th (2009)

This reboot of the slasher series was criticized for its lack of originality, but horror fans looking for a modern update of the iconic villain made it a commercial success.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — Friday The 13th (2009)
Photo: TMDb / New Line Cinema
#8

8. Resident Evil: The Final Chapter

By the sixth film, critics had largely tuned out, calling it repetitive. But the 'Resident Evil' global fanbase remained incredibly loyal, ensuring another financial victory for the long-running series.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — Resident Evil: The Final Chapter
Photo: TMDb / Resident Evil
#9

9. Halloween H20: 20 Years Later

While this installment brought back Jamie Lee Curtis, it received mixed reviews. Fans, however, turned out in record numbers to see Laurie Strode face off against Michael Myers once again.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — Halloween H20: 20 Years Later
Photo: TMDb / Dimension Films
#10

10. The Fog (2005)

John Carpenter's 1980 classic is legendary, the 2005 remake was considered a pale imitation by most critics. Still, it commanded enough interest to make back its budget at the box office.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — The Fog (2005)
Photo: TMDb / Revolution Studios
#11

11. 13 Ghosts

Visually arresting and filled with elaborate ghost designs, this remake failed to impress critics. However, the film's production design and unique premise drew significant audiences to theaters.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — 13 Ghosts
Photo: TMDb / William Castle Productions
#12

12. House Of Wax (2005)

This remake of the classic film was largely marketed around the participation of Paris Hilton. Critics dismissed it as a generic slasher, but the hype generated a strong opening weekend.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — House Of Wax (2005)
Photo: TMDb / Village Roadshow Pictures
#13

13. Ghost Ship

While critics panned the film as hollow and unoriginal, the opening scene became a cult favorite among horror fans, ensuring a surprisingly strong box office run for the nautical horror.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — Ghost Ship
Photo: TMDb / Village Roadshow Pictures
#14

14. The Devil Inside

This possession film was savaged by critics and audience members alike for its ending. Despite this, marketing successfully drove huge numbers to theaters before word-of-mouth killed its momentum.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — The Devil Inside
Photo: TMDb / The Devil Inside
#15

15. Wish Upon

This supernatural thriller centered on a cursed object didn't win over critics, but its premise was enticing enough to secure a solid box office performance for the production team.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — Wish Upon
Photo: TMDb / Broad Green Pictures
#16

16. Truth Or Dare

This Blumhouse horror entry was criticized for its predictable story, but the concept of a lethal version of the party game drew in young audiences seeking a fun weekend watch.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — Truth Or Dare
Photo: TMDb / Blumhouse Productions
#17

17. The Bye Bye Man

Panned heavily for its derivative plot and poor execution, 'The Bye Bye Man' nevertheless found a receptive audience, showcasing the enduring appeal of low-budget supernatural horror.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — The Bye Bye Man
Photo: TMDb / Los Angeles Media Fund
#18

18. Jason X

The 10th 'Friday the 13th' film took Jason to space, earning mockery from critics. Yet, the absurdity made it a must-see event for slasher enthusiasts looking for campy, low-stakes entertainment.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — Jason X
Photo: TMDb / Jason X
#19

19. Annabelle

The first 'Annabelle' film had abysmal critical ratings, but its connection to the critically acclaimed 'The Conjuring' guaranteed it a massive audience on opening weekend.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — Annabelle
Photo: TMDb / Atomic Monster
#20

20. I Know What You Did Last Summer

Following the success of 'Scream,' this teen slasher was a commercial powerhouse despite tepid reviews. It defined a generation of horror fans who cared little for critic opinions.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — I Know What You Did Last Summer
Photo: Wikimedia / Sony Pictures Television, Amazon Studios
#21

21. Ouija

Critics largely panned the adaptation of the iconic board game, calling it generic. However, the film's marketing and the inherent draw of the 'Ouija' brand ensured a highly profitable opening weekend.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — Ouija
Photo: TMDb / Platinum Dunes
#22

22. The Nun

Despite negative critical reception, 'The Nun', part of 'The Conjuring' universe, was an absolute smash hit, proving that the established horror franchise had immense pulling power with general audiences.

22 Horror Movies That Defied Bad Reviews to Become Box Office Giants — The Nun
Photo: TMDb / New Line Cinema

Up Next · Recommended Stories

6 stories