← All stories

Slideshow · Entertainment

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains

How legendary movie auditions flipped prospective heroes into iconic villains.

22 min ago

10 Min Read24 Slides
  1. Famous Auditions That Created Legendary Villains
▼ Visual Countdown

When Hollywood stars read for virtuous heroes in legendary blockbuster franchises, visionary directors often uncover a captivating spark of sinister genius instead.

Swipe or tap ▶ to begin the countdown

©Wikimedia Commons / Gage Skidmore

📖 Complete Countdown Guide

All 23 Entries in this Story

23 Highlights · Full Editorial Review
#1

23. Christopher Mintz-Plasse (Red Mist)

Fresh off breakout comedy acclaim, Mintz-Plasse read for the earnest teenage hero Dave Lizewski in Kick-Ass. Director Matthew Vaughn found his audition hilariously loud and obnoxious, promptly casting him as the mobster heir Red Mist. The role established his trademark chaotic energy on screen.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Christopher Mintz-Plasse (Red Mist)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Gage Skidmore
#2

22. Joe Manganiello (Flash Thompson)

Standing six-foot-five with an imposing frame, Manganiello read for the web-slinging hero opposite Tobey Maguire. Director Sam Raimi realized his physical power was far better suited to schoolyard tormentor Flash Thompson. Manganiello delivered the iconic punch that triggered Peter Parker's spider senses.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Joe Manganiello (Flash Thompson)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Gage Skidmore
#3

21. Alexander Ludwig (Cato)

When casting began for The Hunger Games, Ludwig read extensively for the compassionate baker boy Peeta Mellark. Filmmakers felt his muscular physique and fierce intensity were wasted as a quiet hero. Director Gary Ross offered him Career tribute Cato, creating the most lethal physical menace in the arena.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Alexander Ludwig (Cato)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Kevin Scanlon
#4

20. Karen Gillan (Nebula)

During auditions for Captain America The Winter Soldier, Gillan read for S.H.I.E.L.D. operative Sharon Carter. Marvel casting director Sarah Finn noted her fierce edge and called her back for Guardians of the Galaxy. Shaving her head for the role, Gillan turned Nebula into a deeply layered fan-favorite antagonist.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Karen Gillan (Nebula)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Gage Skidmore
#5

19. Sam Rockwell (Justin Hammer)

During early development for Iron Man, director Jon Favreau considered Rockwell for the titular billionaire hero. While Robert Downey Jr. earned the iconic role, Favreau kept Rockwell in mind for the sequel. Rockwell brought eccentric narcissism and comedic arrogance to Stark's corporate weapons rival.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Sam Rockwell (Justin Hammer)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Gage Skidmore
#6

18. Lee Pace (Ronan The Accuser)

Before Chris Pratt secured the lead, Lee Pace was a top contender for the charismatic outlaw Peter Quill. Director James Gunn recognized Pace's imposing physical stature and dramatic gravitas, pivoting him to Kree zealot Ronan the Accuser. Pace dominated the screen beneath heavy warrior armor and war paint.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Lee Pace (Ronan The Accuser)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Gage Skidmore
#7

17. Rachel McAdams (Regina George)

When auditioning for Mean Girls, McAdams originally read for the naive protagonist Cady Heron. Director Mark Waters recognized that her poised maturity and biting command made Lindsay Lohan visibly intimidated in room readings. Waters offered her the Apex Predator Regina George, cementing a teen comedy classic.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Rachel McAdams (Regina George)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Gage Skidmore
#8

16. Jason Isaacs (Lucius Malfoy)

Director Chris Columbus initially asked Isaacs to audition for celebrity wizard Gilderoy Lockhart. Unimpressed by the reading, producers asked him to read for the sinister Death Eater Lucius Malfoy. Reluctant to play another villain, Isaacs improvised an aristocratic sneer that defined wizarding supremacy.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Jason Isaacs (Lucius Malfoy)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Gage Skidmore
#9

15. Sean Bean (Alec Trevelyan)

When Eon Productions revived the 007 franchise for GoldenEye, Sean Bean was a leading candidate to inherit the hero role from Timothy Dalton. While Pierce Brosnan won the license to kill, producers cast Bean as fallen operative 006 Alec Trevelyan, giving Bond a ruthless mirror-image rival.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Sean Bean (Alec Trevelyan)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / 9EkieraM1
#10

14. Sebastian Stan (The Winter Soldier)

Sebastian Stan went through screen tests in physical attire to play Captain America. While Chris Evans won the star-spangled shield, Marvel executives saw a brooding edge in Stan and cast him as Bucky Barnes. Stan transformed the character into the brainwashed hydra assassin across celebrated sequels.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Sebastian Stan (The Winter Soldier)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Gage Skidmore
#11

13. Iwan Rheon (Ramsay Bolton)

During casting for Game of Thrones, Rheon and Kit Harington were the final two actors competing for honorable Jon Snow. While Harington won the Lord Commander, showrunners remembered Rheon's magnetic menace. They later cast him as Ramsay Bolton, unleashing television's most loathed and terrifying sadist.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Iwan Rheon (Ramsay Bolton)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Gage Skidmore
#12

12. Michael B. Jordan (Erik Killmonger)

Years before Black Panther, Jordan auditioned for the role of high-flying hero Sam Wilson in Captain America The Winter Soldier. While Anthony Mackie won the wings, director Ryan Coogler brought Jordan on as Erik Killmonger. Jordan delivered a fierce, empathetic performance hailed among cinema's best antagonists.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Michael B. Jordan (Erik Killmonger)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Gage Skidmore
#13

11. Mads Mikkelsen (Le Chiffre)

Early in his Hollywood journey, Danish star Mads Mikkelsen read for superhero patriarch Reed Richards in Fantastic Four. Casting directors quickly realized his chilling stillness and piercing gaze belonged on the villainous side. He soon landed James Bond's asthmatic banking adversary Le Chiffre in Casino Royale.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Mads Mikkelsen (Le Chiffre)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Gage Skidmore
#14

10. Christoph Waltz (Col. Hans Landa)

Quentin Tarantino nearly abandoned Inglourious Basterds because he feared the multilingual SS colonel was impossible to play. When Austrian actor Christoph Waltz auditioned, Tarantino realized he found his villainous masterpiece. Waltz swept every major industry award, winning the Oscar for Best Supporting Actor.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Christoph Waltz (Col. Hans Landa)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Manfred Werner
#15

9. Willem Dafoe (Green Goblin)

Before Michael Keaton donned the cape, screenwriter Sam Hamm championed Dafoe to portray Bruce Wayne. While that casting never happened, Dafoe brought unhinged physical brilliance to Norman Osborn in 2002. His shattered mirror dialogues and bone-chilling cackle established the modern superhero supervillain.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Willem Dafoe (Green Goblin)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Georges Biard
#16

8. Christopher Lee (Saruman The White)

Having received J.R.R. Tolkien's personal blessing to play Gandalf, Lee eagerly campaigned for the grey wizard. Director Peter Jackson realized Lee's towering presence and thunderous baritone made him the only actor capable of playing the corrupted wizard Saruman. Lee created one of fantasy's greatest antagonists.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Christopher Lee (Saruman The White)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Avda
#17

7. Nicholas Hoult (Lex Luthor)

Hoult went through exhaustive screen tests in London to lead James Gunn's DC reboot as Superman. When David Corenswet won the heroic cape, Gunn immediately recognized Hoult's razor-sharp intellect and intensity. Gunn offered him the ultimate archenemy role, casting him as the ruthless tech tycoon Lex Luthor.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Nicholas Hoult (Lex Luthor)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Gage Skidmore
#18

6. Alan Rickman (Hans Gruber)

Rickman had established a celebrated career playing romantic and noble stage protagonists across London. Offered the terrorist mastermind Hans Gruber in Die Hard, he almost turned down the Hollywood script. Rickman brought calm European elegance to the role, forever transforming the action movie antagonist.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Alan Rickman (Hans Gruber)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Joella Marano
#19

5. Tom Felton (Draco Malfoy)

During nationwide casting calls for the wizarding saga, Felton dyed his hair brown for Harry and red for Ron. Director Chris Columbus realized his sneering comedic timing was tailor-made for the spoiled Slytherin rival. Felton bleached his hair platinum blonde for a decade, crafting an iconic fantasy bully.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Tom Felton (Draco Malfoy)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Tabercil
#20

4. James Franco (Harry Osborn)

Franco went through extensive screen tests and stunt rehearsals to play the friendly neighborhood webslinger. When Tobey Maguire secured the suit, director Sam Raimi was so captivated by Franco's brooding charisma that he awarded him Harry Osborn without another reading, igniting a tragic three-film villain arc.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — James Franco (Harry Osborn)
Photo: TMDb / James Franco
#21

3. Heath Ledger (The Joker)

Director Christopher Nolan initially approached Ledger about playing Bruce Wayne in Batman Begins. Both felt the young actor was not right for the disciplined vigilante. When scripting The Dark Knight, Nolan offered Ledger the Joker before the screenplay was even finished, resulting in an Oscar-winning performance.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Heath Ledger (The Joker)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Howie
#22

2. Cillian Murphy (Scarecrow)

Murphy donned Val Kilmer's costume during screen tests to play Bruce Wayne for Christopher Nolan. While Nolan chose Christian Bale for the cowl, he was entranced by Murphy's piercing blue eyes and unnerving composure. Nolan cast him as Dr. Jonathan Crane, launching a partnership that culminated in Oppenheimer.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Cillian Murphy (Scarecrow)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Elena Ternovaja
#23

1. Tom Hiddleston (Loki)

Kenneth Branagh put Hiddleston through six weeks of intense weightlifting and combat training to audition for Thor. While Chris Hemsworth took the hammer, Branagh saw a cunning intellect in Hiddleston that matched the trickster god. Hiddleston's magnetic vulnerability turned Loki into Marvel's defining supervillain.

23 Famous Actors Who Auditioned for Heroes but Played Iconic Villains — Tom Hiddleston (Loki)
Photo: Wikimedia Commons / Gage Skidmore & TMDb / Loki

Up Next · Recommended Stories

6 stories