← All stories

Slideshow · Entertainment

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked

Based on Rotten Tomatoes critical consensus scores and box office returns, these forty renowned stars took dramatic creative departures that failed to connect with audiences.

11 min ago

16 Min Read41 Slides
  1. 40 Hollywood Stars Whose Bold Genre Shifts Missed the Mark
▼ Visual Countdown

Hollywood stars frequently risk their box office capital by stepping outside their proven comfort zones, trading beloved comedic personas for dark thrillers or action heroics for serious drama.

Swipe or tap ▶ to begin the countdown

©TMDb / Sylvester Stallone & TMDb / Johnny Depp

📖 Complete Countdown Guide

All 40 Entries in this Story

40 Highlights · Full Editorial Review
#1

40. Arnold Schwarzenegger

After dominating 1980s action cinema, Arnold Schwarzenegger teamed with Danny DeVito and director Ivan Reitman for Junior, playing a research scientist who impregnates himself.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Arnold Schwarzenegger
Photo: TMDb / Arnold Schwarzenegger
#2

39. Michael Cera

Best known for playing stuttering, soft-spoken adolescents in Superbad and Juno, Michael Cera attempted to subvert his persona by playing a rebellious bad-boy alter-ego named Francois Dillinger. Audiences found the stylistic departure jarring rather than subversive, and the film struggled to recoup its modest budget.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Michael Cera
Photo: Wikimedia / Michael Cera
#3

38. Vince Vaughn

Fresh off breakout comedy success in Swingers, Vince Vaughn took an audacious creative leap by portraying psychotic killer Norman Bates in Gus Van Sant's shot-for-shot Psycho remake.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Vince Vaughn
Photo: TMDb / Vince Vaughn
#4

37. Steve Martin

Steve Martin built a comedy legacy on absurd physical humor and heartwarming family hits like Father of the Bride. His departure into gritty, blood-soaked neo-noir in 2001's Novocaine puzzled loyal fans.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Steve Martin
Photo: TMDb / Steve Martin
#5

36. Eddie Murphy

Eddie Murphy reigned supreme across stand-up, action-comedies, and family animation before boarding the 2002 lunar comedy The Adventures of Pluto Nash.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Eddie Murphy
Photo: TMDb / Eddie Murphy
#6

35. Jim Carrey

Jim Carrey had successfully crossed into dramatic territory with The Truman Show and Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, but 2007's The Number 23 proved a bridge too far.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Jim Carrey
Photo: TMDb / Jim Carrey
#7

34. Robert De Niro

A two-time Academy Award winner renowned for Taxi Driver and Raging Bull, Robert De Niro surprised critics by diving headfirst into lowbrow frat humor in 2016's Dirty Grandpa.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Robert De Niro
Photo: TMDb / Robert De Niro
#8

33. Al Pacino

Al Pacino's storied career spans some of the most celebrated dramatic performances in Hollywood history. His appearance as an exaggerated version of himself rapping for Dunkin' Donuts in 2011's Jack and Jill baffled cinephiles.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Al Pacino
Photo: TMDb / ARTE
#9

32. John Travolta

After Quentin Tarantino revitalized his career in 1994, John Travolta poured passion and personal funds into adapting L. Ron Hubbard's sci-fi novel Battlefield Earth. Sporting dreadlocks and alien stilts, Travolta's campy villain performance was savaged by critics, winning nine Razzies and sinking Franchise Pictures.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — John Travolta
Photo: TMDb / John Travolta
#10

31. Nicolas Cage

Nicolas Cage has never hesitated to embrace eccentric roles, but Neil LaBute's 2006 remake of British horror classic The Wicker Man crossed into unintentional hilarity.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Nicolas Cage
Photo: TMDb / Nicolas Cage
#11

30. Halle Berry

After making history as the first Black woman to win the Best Actress Oscar, Halle Berry signed on to lead a standalone Catwoman superhero film. Hampered by frantic editing, a bizarre basketball flirtation scene, and a flimsy script, the film flopped disastrously.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Halle Berry
Photo: TMDb / Halle Berry
#12

29. Mike Myers

Mike Myers dominated comedy for fifteen years through Wayne's World, Austin Powers, and Shrek. When he attempted to combine hockey sports comedy with spiritual satire in 2008's The Love Guru, the result was a toxic mix of bathroom humor and tired puns.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Mike Myers
Photo: TMDb / Mike Myers
#13

28. Ben Affleck

In the early 2000s, Ben Affleck was Hollywood's golden boy leading major studio thrillers and dramas. That momentum ground to a halt with 2003's Gigli, an awkward blend of mob violence, romantic comedy, and tone-deaf dialogue.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Ben Affleck
Photo: TMDb / Ben Affleck
#14

27. Will Smith

Will Smith built an untouchable box office streak on charm, warmth, and electric wit across Men in Black and Independence Day. For After Earth, Smith deliberately stripped away his charisma to play a stern, emotionless commander stranded with son Jaden.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Will Smith
Photo: TMDb / Will Smith
#15

26. Johnny Depp

Hoping to replicate the multi-billion-dollar success of Pirates of the Caribbean, Disney spent over two hundred million dollars on 2013's The Lone Ranger.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Johnny Depp
Photo: TMDb / Johnny Depp
#16

25. Tom Cruise

Tom Cruise is cinema's preeminent modern action hero, known for rigorous stunt work and consistent box office dominance. However, Universal's attempt to build a Marvel-style Dark Universe around Cruise in 2017's The Mummy backfired.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Tom Cruise
Photo: TMDb / Tom Cruise
#17

24. George Clooney

George Clooney was poised to become Hollywood's definitive leading man when director Joel Schumacher cast him in 1997's Batman & Robin.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — George Clooney
Photo: TMDb / George Clooney
#18

23. Sandra Bullock

Sandra Bullock achieved peak Hollywood acclaim in 2009 by winning an Academy Award for The Blind Side. That same weekend, she won a Razzie for All About Steve, an unsettling comedy where she played an obsessive crossword creator stalking Bradley Cooper.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Sandra Bullock
Photo: TMDb / Sandra Bullock
#19

22. Matthew McConaughey

Following his celebrated career resurgence known as the McConaissance, Matthew McConaughey signed on to play the villainous Man in Black in Stephen King's The Dark Tower. Squeezing eight sprawling fantasy novels into a brisk 95-minute PG-13 action flick alienated both diehard book readers and general moviegoers.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Matthew McConaughey
Photo: TMDb / Matthew McConaughey
#20

21. Colin Farrell

Oliver Stone's 2004 historical epic Alexander had all the ingredients of a masterwork: an enormous budget, epic battles, and star Colin Farrell as the ancient Macedonian conqueror.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Colin Farrell
Photo: TMDb / Colin Farrell
#21

20. Taylor Lautner

Riding high on the global Twilight phenomenon, Taylor Lautner was positioned as Hollywood's next premier action hero in John Singleton's thriller Abduction.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Taylor Lautner
Photo: TMDb / Taylor Lautner
#22

19. Chris Hemsworth

Chris Hemsworth possessed global fame and physical authority as Marvel's Thor, but casting him as an elite computer hacker in Michael Mann's 2015 thriller Blackhat proved unconvincing.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Chris Hemsworth
Photo: TMDb / Chris Hemsworth
#23

18. Dwayne Johnson

Before establishing his billion-dollar action brand with Fast Five and Jumanji, Dwayne Johnson followed the Arnold Schwarzenegger playbook of family-friendly comedy. In 2010's Tooth Fairy, Johnson strapped on wings and tights to grant wishes to children.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Dwayne Johnson
Photo: TMDb / Dwayne Johnson
#24

17. Vin Diesel

Vin Diesel is undeniably potent behind the wheel of a Dodge Charger, but his attempt to launch an original urban fantasy franchise in The Last Witch Hunter missed the target.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Vin Diesel
Photo: TMDb / Vin Diesel
#25

16. Mark Wahlberg

Known for gritty Boston dramas and hard-hitting action movies like The Departed and Shooter, Mark Wahlberg took a sharp turn into M. Night Shyamalan's environmental horror The Happening.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Mark Wahlberg
Photo: TMDb / Mark Wahlberg
#26

15. Bruce Willis

Hot off Die Hard 2, Bruce Willis cashed in his massive creative clout to co-write and star in 1991's Hudson Hawk, an anarchic screwball comedy about a cat burglar singing show tunes during heists. Baffled by cartoonish sound effects and frantic tone shifts, audiences stayed away, handing TriStar a thirty-million loss.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Bruce Willis
Photo: TMDb / Bruce Willis
#27

14. Kevin Costner

Kevin Costner was an Oscar-winning darling after Dances with Wolves and Field of Dreams. His pivot into grand-scale post-apocalyptic sci-fi in 1995's Waterworld was plagued by sinking sets, spiraling production costs, and critical snark.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Kevin Costner
Photo: TMDb / Kevin Costner
#28

13. Sean Connery

Screen legend Sean Connery commanded respect across five decades of cinema before starring in 2003's steampunk superhero adaptation The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Sean Connery
Photo: TMDb / Sean Connery
#29

12. Harrison Ford

Harrison Ford rarely misses when anchoring action spectacles, but 2011's Cowboys and Aliens proved that combining two beloved genres doesn't guarantee a hit.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Harrison Ford
Photo: TMDb / Harrison Ford
#30

11. Mel Gibson

Mel Gibson built an iconic career on visceral violence and gritty intensity in Mad Max, Lethal Weapon, and Braveheart. His turn into high-concept romantic comedy in 2000's What Women Want saw Gibson waxing his legs and dancing with a blower in a bathroom.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Mel Gibson
Photo: TMDb / Mel Gibson
#31

10. Tom Hanks

Brian De Palma's 1990 adaptation of Tom Wolfe's biting satirical novel The Bonfire of the Vanities is widely studied as a legendary Hollywood blunder.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Tom Hanks
Photo: TMDb / Tom Hanks
#32

9. Robin Williams

In 2002, Robin Williams shocked loyal fans by shedding his manic comedy persona to play chilling loner Sy Parrish in psychological thriller One Hour Photo. While critics praised Williams' unnerving intensity and restraint, general audiences expecting Mrs.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Robin Williams
Photo: TMDb / Robin Williams
#33

8. Adam Sandler

Adam Sandler took a dramatic risk in 2007's Reign Over Me, portraying a grieving man who lost his family on September 11.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Adam Sandler
Photo: TMDb / Adam Sandler
#34

7. Keanu Reeves

Universal gambled one hundred and seventy-five million dollars on 2013's 47 Ronin, blending authentic Japanese samurai history with fantasy witches, dragons, and martial arts.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Keanu Reeves
Photo: TMDb / Keanu Reeves
#35

6. Liam Neeson

After late-career thriller Taken turned him into a sixty-year-old action superstar, Liam Neeson signed on to Peter Berg's 2012 board game adaptation Battleship. Confined mostly to a control room shouting naval orders between extraterrestrial missile barrages, Neeson's brief appearance felt like an uninspired cash grab.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Liam Neeson
Photo: TMDb / Liam Neeson
#36

5. Will Ferrell

The legendary comedic chemistry of Step Brothers and Talladega Nights evaporated completely in 2018's Holmes and Watson. Attempting a period slapstick mystery, Will Ferrell and John C. Reilly resorted to selfie jokes and dated pop culture references, earning a rare zero percent rating on Rotten Tomatoes from critics.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Will Ferrell
Photo: TMDb / Will Ferrell
#37

4. Brad Pitt

Before establishing his dramatic authority in Se7en and Fight Club, a young Brad Pitt starred in Ralph Bakshi's 1992 mixed-media fantasy Cool World.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Brad Pitt
Photo: TMDb / Brad Pitt
#38

3. Leonardo DiCaprio

After Titanic made him the most adored romantic idol on the planet, Leonardo DiCaprio deliberately chose Danny Boyle's dark, psychological backpacker drama The Beach to shatter his heartthrob image.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Leonardo DiCaprio
Photo: TMDb / Leonardo DiCaprio
#39

2. Christian Bale

Hot off The Dark Knight, Christian Bale joined 2009's Terminator Salvation as resistance leader John Connor. Between director clashes and an infamous leaked onset audio recording, the grim, dirt-smeared post-apocalyptic actioner lacked heart, failing to revive the beloved sci-fi franchise and disappointing fans.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Christian Bale
Photo: TMDb / Christian Bale
#40

1. Sylvester Stallone

In one of Hollywood's most legendary rivalries, Arnold Schwarzenegger falsely leaked that he wanted to star in Stop. Or My Mom Will Shoot, tricking Sylvester Stallone into quickly signing on.

40 Famous Actors Who Tried Different Film Genres and Stumbled, Ranked — Sylvester Stallone
Photo: TMDb / Sylvester Stallone

Up Next · Recommended Stories

6 stories