← All stories

Slideshow · Tv Film

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns

Before Fame Called, These Icons Prepared To Take Holy Vows

26 Oct 2026

8 Min Read21 Slides
  1. Split cover showing actor Tom Cruise speaking on a panel beside the grand altar of the Sanctuary of Fatima basilica
▼ Visual Countdown

Long before red carpets and sold-out arenas, many household names seriously prepared for a life inside the Catholic Church or the clergy. From strict minor seminaries to cloistered convents, biographical records as of October 2026 reveal how close these stars came to taking lifelong vows.

Swipe or tap ▶ to begin the countdown

©Wikimedia / Harald Krichel & Wikimedia / Nicolas Genin

📖 Complete Countdown Guide

All 20 Entries in this Story

20 Highlights · Full Editorial Review
#1

20. Tom Baker, Six Years As A Monastic Brother

Before playing the Fourth Doctor on BBC's Doctor Who, Liverpool native Tom Baker left home at age 15 to join the Brothers of Ploermel in Jersey. He spent six years living in the monastic order before realizing at age 21 that celibate life was not his true calling and joining the Royal Army Medical Corps.

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns — Tom Baker, Six Years As A Monastic Brother
Photo: TMDb / BBC
#2

19. Pete Postlethwaite, From Seminary To The Stage

Raised in a Catholic family in Cheshire, England, character actor Pete Postlethwaite attended St Mary's College in Crosby as a teenager with plans to become a Roman Catholic priest. After deciding against ordination, he trained as a drama teacher at St Mary's University in Twickenham before launching his film career.

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns — Pete Postlethwaite, From Seminary To The Stage
Photo: TMDb / Prominent Features
#3

18. Richard Coles, From Pop Charts To The Pulpit

In the 1980s, multi-instrumentalist Richard Coles scored three UK top-ten hits alongside Jimmy Somerville in the synth-pop duo The Communards. In 1990, he left the music industry to study theology at King's College London and the College of the Resurrection, becoming an ordained Church of England priest in 2005.

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns — Richard Coles, From Pop Charts To The Pulpit
Photo: Wikimedia / PhilipRomanoPhoto
#4

17. Carson Daly, The Broadcast Convert

Raised in a devout Catholic family in Santa Monica, Carson Daly attended Loyola Marymount University and deeply considered entering the priesthood. Before enrolling in a seminary, a California radio internship sparked a broadcasting career that led to MTV and NBC's Today show.

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns — Carson Daly, The Broadcast Convert
Photo: Wikimedia / United States Army (Photo Credit: Spc
#5

16. James McAvoy, The Aspiring Missionary

Raised by his maternal grandparents in Glasgow and educated at St Thomas Aquinas Secondary School, McAvoy intended to join the Catholic priesthood as a missionary. By age 16, he realized he mainly wanted to travel the world, and a school visit by actor David Hayman steered him toward cinema.

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns — James McAvoy, The Aspiring Missionary
Photo: Wikimedia / Gage Skidmore
#6

15. Alex Trebek, The Trappist Novice

While studying Thomistic philosophy under Oblate priests at the University of Ottawa, the future Jeopardy host seriously explored a Catholic vocation. After living at a Trappist monastery in Quebec for a summer, he concluded that a strict vow of silence did not suit his love of talking.

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns — Alex Trebek, The Trappist Novice
Photo: DVIDS / Jim Greenhill
#7

14. LeVar Burton, The Four-Year Seminarian

At age 13, LeVar Burton enrolled at St. Pius X Minor Seminary in Galt, California, intending to enter the Roman Catholic priesthood. After questioning church dogma at age 17, he switched to a drama scholarship at the University of Southern California and landed his breakout role in Roots.

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns — LeVar Burton, The Four-Year Seminarian
Photo: Wikimedia / Encabulator
#8

13. Madonna, The Convent Dreamer

Before challenging religious imagery in pop music videos, a young Madonna Louise Ciccone attended St. Frederick and St. Andrew Catholic schools in Michigan. She admired the discipline and flowing habits of the teaching sisters so deeply that she planned to join a convent before discovering dance.

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns — Madonna, The Convent Dreamer
Photo: Wikimedia / xiquinhosilva
#9

12. Olalla Oliveros, The Fatima Convert

After building a lucrative career in Spanish commercials, modeling, and television, Olalla Oliveros experienced a life-altering spiritual awakening during a visit to the Sanctuary of Fatima in Portugal. At age 36, she walked away from entertainment to become Sister Olalla del Si de Maria in the Order of Saint Michael.

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns — Olalla Oliveros, The Fatima Convert
Photo: TMDb / Olalla Oliveros
#10

11. Dolores Hart, From Elvis Co-Star To Benedictine Prioress

After giving Elvis Presley his first on-screen kiss in the 1957 film Loving You and making ten movies in five years, Dolores Hart stunned Hollywood in 1963. At age 24, she called off her wedding engagement and entered the cloistered Benedictine Abbey of Regina Laudis in Connecticut.

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns — Dolores Hart, From Elvis Co-Star To Benedictine Prioress
Photo: Wikimedia / Hugo van Gelderen, Anefo
#11

10. Anjelica Huston, The Irish Convent Pupil

Raised on a country estate in Galway, Ireland, by director John Huston, young Anjelica attended the Benedictine convent school at Kylemore Abbey. Despite her father warning the nuns not to indoctrinate her, she developed a fierce childhood desire to become a nun before entering cinema.

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns — Anjelica Huston, The Irish Convent Pupil
Photo: Wikimedia / Mingle Media TV
#12

9. Eva Mendes, The Vow Of Poverty Dealbreaker

Growing up in a working-class Cuban-American family in Los Angeles, Eva Mendes dreamed of becoming a Catholic nun while also promising to buy her mother a home. At age ten, her older sister informed her that nuns receive no salary, immediately ending her convent ambitions.

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns — Eva Mendes, The Vow Of Poverty Dealbreaker
Photo: Wikimedia / Nicolas Genin
#13

8. Anne Hathaway, Choosing Family Over The Convent

Throughout her childhood in Millburn, New Jersey, Anne Hathaway felt a strong calling to become a Roman Catholic nun. At age 15, when her older brother Michael came out as gay, Hathaway and her family left the Catholic Church because she refused to support a faith that did not fully accept him.

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns — Anne Hathaway, Choosing Family Over The Convent
Photo: Wikimedia / Harald Krichel
#14

7. Michael Moore, The Michigan Seminary Student

Educated by nuns at St. John the Evangelist parish school near Flint, Michigan, documentary director Michael Moore enrolled at St. John's Diocesan Seminary in Plymouth at age 14. After one year of priestly training, he transferred to Davison High School and turned toward journalism.

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns — Michael Moore, The Michigan Seminary Student
Photo: Wikimedia / Nicolas Genin
#15

6. Danny Boyle, Saved For Cinema By Father Conway

After serving as an altar boy for eight years in Lancashire, England, Danny Boyle applied to transfer from Thornleigh Salesian College to St Joseph's Seminary near Wigan at age 14. His local priest, Father Conway, pulled him aside and advised him not to join, later inspiring Boyle's directing career.

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns — Danny Boyle, Saved For Cinema By Father Conway
Photo: TMDb / Danny Boyle: Retrospective
#16

5. Jack White, Choosing The Amplifier Over The Altar

Growing up as an altar boy in Detroit, Jack White was accepted into a Catholic seminary in Wisconsin to study for the priesthood. Just before enrolling, he bought a new guitar amplifier and discovered the seminary forbade bringing electric instruments, prompting him to choose public school and rock music instead.

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns — Jack White, Choosing The Amplifier Over The Altar
Photo: Wikimedia / White House Staff
#17

4. Dan Aykroyd, The Prankster Seminarian

Raised in a strict Catholic household in Ottawa, Canada, the future Ghostbusters creator attended St. Pius X Preparatory Seminary up to age 17 with plans to become a priest. High-spirited teenage pranks and a growing passion for improvisational comedy led him out of the seminary and onto Saturday Night Live.

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns — Dan Aykroyd, The Prankster Seminarian
Photo: Wikimedia / Dan Aykroyd
#18

3. Gabriel Byrne, Five Years In The Seminary

Recruited from Dublin at age 11, Irish actor Gabriel Byrne spent nearly five years studying at St. Richard's College, a Christian Brothers junior seminary in Worcestershire, England. After leaving at age 15 when he realized the priesthood was not his vocation, he studied archaeology and drama.

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns — Gabriel Byrne, Five Years In The Seminary
Photo: Wikimedia / mandy_m
#19

2. Martin Scorsese, From Cathedral College To Cinema

Growing up in Manhattan's Little Italy, Martin Scorsese entered Cathedral College preparatory seminary at age 14 intending to join the Catholic priesthood. After struggling with the strict discipline and academic demands during his first year, he transferred to New York University to study cinema.

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns — Martin Scorsese, From Cathedral College To Cinema
Photo: Wikimedia / Harald Krichel
#20

1. Tom Cruise, The Franciscan Seminary Scholarship

Years before Hollywood stardom and Scientology, 14-year-old Tom Cruise enrolled at the Franciscan St. Francis Seminary in Cincinnati, Ohio, on a church scholarship to become a Catholic priest. His stay ended after one year when he and classmates were asked to leave following a liquor-cabinet infraction.

Famous People Who Nearly Became Priests Or Nuns — Tom Cruise, The Franciscan Seminary Scholarship
Photo: Wikimedia / Gabriel Hutchinson

More galleries

Up Next · Recommended Stories

6 stories