← All stories

Slideshow

16 Most Horrific Botched Executions in History

From the teenager who survived the electric chair to the drug testing scandal that halted Christa Pike’s death warrant, explore history’s most harrowing execution failures.

25 Oct 2026

7 Min Read17 Slides
  1. 16 Most Horrific Botched Executions in History visual representation.
▼ Visual Countdown

From 19th-century gallows failures to the statewide drug contamination scandal that halted Christa Pike’s execution in Tennessee, explore the most notorious execution botches in history.

Swipe or tap ▶ to begin the countdown

©Wikimedia / Bill Allen

📖 Complete Countdown Guide

All 16 Entries in this Story

16 Highlights · Full Editorial Review
#1

16. Pedro Medina (1997)

When Florida officials executed Pedro Medina in 'Old Sparky,' a foot-long flame shot from the headpiece because the sponge had been soaked in flammable tap water instead of saline solution.

16 Most Horrific Botched Executions in History — Pedro Medina (1997)
Photo: Wikimedia / Florida Department of Corrections Public Domain
#2

15. William Vandiver (1985)

Vandiver remained alive after the initial 2,300-volt surge, forcing prison staff to reapply four additional electrical charges over seventeen agonizing minutes before he was pronounced dead.

16 Most Horrific Botched Executions in History — William Vandiver (1985)
Photo: Wikimedia / Steve Shook from Moscow, Idaho, USA
#3

14. Stephen McCoy (1989)

During McCoy's execution in Huntsville, the intravenous tube disconnected and sprayed chemicals, causing violent chest heaving and choking while technicians frantically reconnected the line.

16 Most Horrific Botched Executions in History — Stephen McCoy (1989)
Photo: Wikimedia / Nick DiFonzo from Houston, Texas
#4

13. Jimmy Lee Gray (1983)

Gray struggled violently against cyanide fumes, groaning and thrashing against an iron pipe in the chair for eight minutes until prison officials abruptly cleared the witness room.

16 Most Horrific Botched Executions in History — Jimmy Lee Gray (1983)
Photo: Wikimedia / WhisperToMe
#5

12. Joseph Clark (2006)

After Clark's vein collapsed, he sat up on the gurney and told staff, 'It don't work.' Executioners closed the privacy curtains for ninety minutes while hunting for a usable vein.

16 Most Horrific Botched Executions in History — Joseph Clark (2006)
Photo: Wikimedia / Ohio. Correctional Institution Inspection Committee
#6

11. William Kemmler (1890)

The inaugural 1890 electric chair test failed when the initial 17-second surge left Kemmler breathing. A hasty second 2,000-volt charge horrified observers in Auburn, New York.

16 Most Horrific Botched Executions in History — William Kemmler (1890)
Photo: Wikimedia / Miscellaneous Items in High Demand, PPOC, Library of Congress
#7

10. Angel Nieves Diaz (2006)

Catheters pushed entirely through Diaz’s veins into soft muscle tissue, inflicting chemical burns over 34 agonizing minutes that prompted Governor Jeb Bush to suspend all executions in Florida.

16 Most Horrific Botched Executions in History — Angel Nieves Diaz (2006)
Photo: Wikimedia / WhisperToMe
#8

9. Thomas Creech (2024)

Idaho’s longest-serving death row inmate survived his execution after medical staff spent over an hour attempting to establish lines in his arms and legs before halting the procedure.

16 Most Horrific Botched Executions in History — Thomas Creech (2024)
Photo: Wikimedia / James Du Toit
#9

8. Joseph Wood (2014)

Executioners injected Wood fifteen times with an experimental drug cocktail. The procedure lasted 117 minutes while his attorneys filed emergency federal stays from the witness gallery.

16 Most Horrific Botched Executions in History — Joseph Wood (2014)
Photo: Wikimedia / Marine 69-71
#10

7. Doyle Lee Hamm (2018)

Suffering from lymphatic cancer, Hamm endured two and a half hours of invasive punctures to his legs, groin, and bladder before Alabama called off the execution due to vein access failure.

16 Most Horrific Botched Executions in History — Doyle Lee Hamm (2018)
Photo: Wikimedia / WhisperToMe
#11

6. Clayton Lockett (2014)

A torn vein allowed lethal drugs to leak under Lockett's skin. He regained consciousness, thrashing and groaning, before dying of a massive heart attack 43 minutes later.

16 Most Horrific Botched Executions in History — Clayton Lockett (2014)
Photo: Wikimedia / Charles Duggar Derivative work MagentaGreen
#12

5. Kenneth Smith (2022 & 2024)

After surviving a four-hour botched IV attempt in 2022, Smith was subjected to the world’s first nitrogen gas execution in 2024, experiencing minutes of heavy convulsions on the gurney.

16 Most Horrific Botched Executions in History — Kenneth Smith (2022 & 2024)
Photo: Wikimedia / Patrick Huber
#13

4. John 'Babbacombe' Lee (1885)

Known as 'The Man They Couldn't Hang,' Lee survived three trapdoor failures on the Exeter Prison gallows despite the mechanism working perfectly in testing. His sentence was commuted to life.

16 Most Horrific Botched Executions in History — John 'Babbacombe' Lee (1885)
Photo: Wikimedia / Stephen Richards
#14

3. Romell Broom (2009)

Executioners spent over two hours attempting to find a viable vein in Broom’s arms and legs, piercing him eighteen times while he wept in pain. Governor Ted Strickland granted a reprieve; Broom lived until 2020.

16 Most Horrific Botched Executions in History — Romell Broom (2009)
Photo: Wikimedia / FunksBrother
#15

2. Willie Francis (1946)

When Louisiana's portable chair 'Gruesome Gertie' misfired, 17-year-old Francis cried 'Let me breathe!' The Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that a second execution was constitutional, and he died in the chair a year later.

16 Most Horrific Botched Executions in History — Willie Francis (1946)
Photo: Wikimedia / Associated Press Public Domain (1946)
#16

1. Christa Pike (1995–2026)

Sentenced to death at age twenty, Christa Pike remains Tennessee's only female death row inmate. Her scheduled execution was halted indefinitely after an independent investigation exposed statewide lethal injection drug contamination.

16 Most Horrific Botched Executions in History — Christa Pike (1995–2026)
Photo: Wikimedia / Public Domain Archive

More galleries

Up Next · Recommended Stories

6 stories