← All stories

Slideshow · Lifestyle

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them

Every fourth Thursday of November, millions of families gather around a feast steeped in tradition. Yet few holiday staples arrived on the table by accident. From depression-era canned soups to indigenous trade routes, explore the documented histories and corporate inventions behind 20 classic Thanksgiving dishes.

42 min ago

8 Min Read21 Slides
  1. 20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes
▼ Visual Countdown

Historical reporting from the Smithsonian Institution, the Library of Congress, and the National Museum of American History reveals that many holiday essentials are modern inventions. While roast fowl and corn date back centuries, casseroles and canned jellies emerged through mid-century corporate test kitchens.

Swipe or tap ▶ to begin the countdown

©Wikimedia / Mashed potato & Wikimedia / theogeo

📖 Complete Countdown Guide

All 20 Entries in this Story

20 Highlights · Full Editorial Review
#1

20. Canned Cranberry Sauce

Fresh cranberries spoiled quickly during rail shipment, limiting sales to a short six-week window. Urann bought a Massachusetts bog and began boiling damaged berries with pectin to create stable jellied cylinders. Ocean Spray distributed the iconic ribbed cans nationally starting in 1941.

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them — Canned Cranberry Sauce
Photo: Wikimedia / FoodCraftLab
#2

19. Pumpkin Pie

Seventeenth-century New England colonists lacked pastry pie crusts and specialized baking pans. Cooks hollowed whole pumpkins, filled the cavities with spiced milk, honey, and eggs, and roasted the gourds directly in hot ash embers. Amelia Simmons printed the first crust-based pumpkin pie recipe in 1796.

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them — Pumpkin Pie
Photo: Wikimedia / Pumpkin pie
#3

18. Turkey Gravy

Medieval European cooks used unthickened pan drippings called jus to moisten roasted game. American holiday cooks refined the sauce by adding a flour roux and simmered giblet stock to roasting pan remnants. The thickened gravy prevented dry roasted meat slices from losing flavor on dinner plates.

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them — Turkey Gravy
Photo: Wikimedia / Prayitno, Thank you for (12 millions +)
#4

17. Mashed Potatoes

Indigenous farmers in the Andes domesticated potatoes thousands of years ago, but European tables resisted them for generations. Mary Randolph published the first American recipe for mashed potatoes with butter and milk in her 1824 guide, The Virginia House-Wife. The side became ubiquitous by the 1880s.

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them — Mashed Potatoes
Photo: Wikimedia / Mashed potato
#5

16. Macaroni And Cheese

Jefferson encountered baked macaroni in Paris and northern Italy during the 1780s. Enslaved chef James Hemings mastered the preparation, recreating baked macaroni with cheddar cheese for an 1802 White House dinner. The baked casserole spread through southern celebrations over the next two centuries.

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them — Macaroni And Cheese
Photo: Wikimedia / Antilived
#6

15. Cornbread Stuffing

While northern cooks favored stale wheat bread, southern cooks relied on coarse yellow cornmeal pans. After baking skillet cornbread, cooks crumbled and dried the pieces before tossing them with celery, sage, and giblet broth. The savory mixture became known simply as dressing throughout the South.

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them — Cornbread Stuffing
Photo: Pixabay / IstiakHossen
#7

14. Pecan Pie

Native Americans along the Mississippi River harvested wild pecans for centuries. Nineteenth-century Texas cooks baked early variations with molasses, but the modern Karo syrup formula emerged in the 1930s. The Corn Products Refining Company printed the easy recipe directly onto commercial syrup labels.

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them — Pecan Pie
Photo: Pixabay / sinapy
#8

13. Sweet Potato Pie

Enslaved African cooks in the American South substituted indigenous sweet potatoes for traditional African yams. Using baking techniques developed in plantation kitchens, they added nutmeg, allspice, butter, and eggs. The spiced custard pie became a foundational centerpiece of Black holiday culture.

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them — Sweet Potato Pie
Photo: Wikimedia / Sweet potato pie
#9

12. Roast Turkey

Edward Winslow recorded that Plymouth colonists ate wild fowl in 1621, but turkey was not mandatory. Godey's Lady's Book editor Sarah Josepha Hale spent thirty years writing editorials and lobbying presidents for a national holiday centered on roasted turkey. Abraham Lincoln made it official in 1863.

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them — Roast Turkey
Photo: Wikimedia / theogeo
#10

11. Green Bean Casserole

Reilly led the Campbell Soup Company home economics team in Camden, New Jersey. She created the Green Bean Bake using six common pantry staples, including canned cream of mushroom soup and french-fried onions. Campbell estimates the recipe now appears on twenty million holiday tables each year.

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them — Green Bean Casserole
Photo: Wikimedia / Stephanie Clifford from Arlington, VA, USA
#11

10. Parker House Rolls

Baker Ward baked at Boston's Parker House Hotel during the 1870s. Legend holds that he hurled uncooked dough into an oven during an argument with a hotel guest, causing the folded rolls to bake with crisp shells and soft, hollow centers. The recipe became a national sensation by 1880.

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them — Parker House Rolls
Photo: Wikimedia / l_zimberoff
#12

9. Brussels Sprouts With Bacon

Dutch scientist Hans van Doorn identified specific glucosinolates causing extreme bitterness in traditional Brussels sprouts during the 1990s. Breeders crossed older heirloom seeds to produce naturally sweeter buds. Roasting them with smoked bacon became an American holiday favorite shortly after 2000.

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them — Brussels Sprouts With Bacon
Photo: Pixabay / PublicDomainPictures
#13

8. Creamed Corn

Native American cooks scraped milky pulp from mature summer maize ears to create rich porridge bases. European settlers adapted the method by blending sweet corn scrapings with fresh dairy butter and cream. Commercial canning companies mechanized the cream-style process in the late nineteenth century.

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them — Creamed Corn
Photo: Wikimedia / Wikimedia Contributor
#14

7. Cranberry Relish

Unlike cooked jellies, this raw uncooked condiment blends fresh tart berries with whole unpeeled oranges and sugar. Cooking authority Ruth Wakefield featured raw relish in 1930, but radio broadcasts by food editors in the 1950s made it an annual staple across American kitchens.

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them — Cranberry Relish
Photo: Wikimedia / Burkhard Mücke
#15

6. Candied Yams

Sweet potatoes sustained early southern settlements, but sugar syrups transformed them into holiday desserts. Fannie Merritt Farmer printed one of the first printed recipes for glazed sweet potatoes in the 1896 Boston Cooking-School Cook Book. She boiled tubers in butter and brown sugar until glossy.

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them — Candied Yams
Photo: Wikimedia / Famartin
#16

5. Butternut Squash Soup

Charles Leggett crossed pumpkin and gooseneck squash varieties on his farm in Stow, Massachusetts, in 1944. He named the result butternut because the cooked flesh felt smooth as butter and sweet as a nut. New England cooks adopted the hardy squash for creamy autumn holiday soups within a decade.

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them — Butternut Squash Soup
Photo: Wikimedia / Missvain
#17

4. Oyster Stuffing

In the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, American coastal waters held massive oyster reefs. New England and Chesapeake cooks chopped raw oysters into stale bread crumbs to stretch scarce meat supplies. By the late nineteenth century, overharvesting turned the humble filler into an upscale holiday tradition.

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them — Oyster Stuffing
Photo: Wikimedia / Famartin
#18

3. Creamed Onions

British colonists carried white pearl onions to New England, pairing them with heavy cream and nutmeg. Nineteenth-century domestic manuals praised boiled onions as a medicinal digestive aid during rich multi-course feasts. The dish remained a formal holiday standard in Boston households through the 1950s.

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them — Creamed Onions
Photo: Wikimedia / Raimond Spekking
#19

2. Sweet Potato Casserole With Marshmallows

In 1917, the Angelus Marshmallow Company commissioned culinary author Janet McKenzie Hill to develop recipes featuring mass-produced marshmallows. Her booklet paired baked sweet potatoes with a melted candy topping. The combination became an immediate marketing triumph and enduring holiday fixture.

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them — Sweet Potato Casserole With Marshmallows
Photo: Wikimedia / Willis Lam
#20

1. Ambrosia Salad

Maria Massey Barringer published the earliest known recipe in her 1867 cookbook, Dixie Cookery. Oranges and fresh coconut were costly winter imports in the late nineteenth century. Hostesses served the dish in crystal bowls as a festive display of seasonal wealth.

20 Classic Thanksgiving Dishes & Surprising History Behind Them — Ambrosia Salad
Photo: Wikimedia / Marshall Astor from Olympia, WA, United

Up Next · Recommended Stories

6 stories