← All stories

Slideshow · Travel

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End

New York has faced Revolutionary fires, the 1970s fiscal crisis, and pandemic shutdowns, yet its defining landmarks still stand. Based on NYC Landmarks Preservation Commission records, the National Park Service, and reporting by The New York Times, this countdown tracks 20 icons that outlived predictions of doom.

55 min ago

8 Min Read21 Slides
  1. Statue of Liberty illuminated at twilight in New York Harbor
▼ Visual Countdown

New York has faced Revolutionary fires, the 1970s fiscal crisis, and pandemic shutdowns, yet its defining landmarks still stand. Based on NYC Landmarks Preservation Commission records, the National Park Service, and reporting by The New York Times, this countdown tracks 20 icons that outlived predictions of doom.

Swipe or tap ▶ to begin the countdown

©Wikimedia / William Warby & Wikimedia / Terabass

📖 Complete Countdown Guide

All 20 Entries in this Story

20 Highlights · Full Editorial Review
#1

#20 Fraunces Tavern

George Washington bade farewell to his Continental Army officers in Fraunces Tavern's Long Room on December 4, 1783. After 19th-century fires and a deadly 1975 bombing damaged the building, the Sons of the Revolution restored the Pearl Street landmark. It operates as a museum and tavern.

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End — Fraunces Tavern
Photo: Wikimedia / Epicgenius
#2

#19 Eldridge Street Synagogue

Opened in 1887 by Eastern European Jewish immigrants, the sanctuary fell into severe disrepair by the 1950s as its congregation shrank. Preservationists launched a 20-year, $20 million restoration in 1986, and the building reopened as the Museum at Eldridge Street in 2007.

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End — Eldridge Street Synagogue
Photo: Wikimedia / Alexisrael
#3

#18 Jefferson Market Library

Built in 1877 as a courthouse and market, the building stood empty after 1945 and faced demolition by city planners. Neighbor Margot Gayle led a campaign that convinced New York Public Library trustees to convert the brick tower into a neighborhood branch in 1967.

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End — Jefferson Market Library
Photo: Wikimedia / Kidfly182
#4

#17 Stonewall Inn

Following the June 1969 riots, the original Stonewall Inn closed within months and cycled through unrelated storefronts on Christopher Street. A new bar reopened in part of the space in 1990, and President Barack Obama designated the site a U.S. National Monument in 2016.

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End — Stonewall Inn
Photo: Wikimedia / Gryffindor
#5

#16 The Dakota

Developer Edward Clark opened The Dakota at 72nd Street and Central Park West in 1884, when Manhattan's Upper West Side was mostly farmland and shanties. The gabled landmark instead anchored Central Park West's residential boom and became one of the city's most famous co-ops.

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End — The Dakota
Photo: Wikimedia / Christian David
#6

#15 Washington Square Arch

In the 1950s, master builder Robert Moses proposed extending Fifth Avenue as a sunken roadway straight through Washington Square Park. Greenwich Village activists, including Jane Jacobs, defeated the highway plan in 1958, keeping the 77-foot marble arch as a pedestrian centerpiece.

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End — Washington Square Arch
Photo: Wikimedia / Michael Sean Gallagher from London, United Kingd
#7

#14 Coney Island Cyclone

Opened on June 26, 1927, the Cyclone survived declining boardwalk crowds and a 1975 city plan to tear it down to expand the New York Aquarium. Operators Dewey and Jerome Albert leased the ride that year, and the city granted it official landmark protection in 1988.

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End — Coney Island Cyclone
Photo: Wikimedia / Leonard J. DeFrancisci
#8

#13 Apollo Theater

After launching careers from Ella Fitzgerald to James Brown, the Apollo Theater closed in 1976 during Harlem's economic downturn and briefly operated as a movie house. Percy Sutton's group bought it in 1981, and city landmark status in 1983 helped anchor its long-term comeback.

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End — Apollo Theater
Photo: Wikimedia / Adjoajo
#9

#12 St. Patrick's Cathedral

When Archbishop John Hughes broke ground at Fifth Avenue and 50th Street in 1858, skeptics dubbed it Hughes' Folly because Midtown was still rural pastureland. Completed in 1879, the marble cathedral survived the 1970s grime and underwent a $177 million restoration completed in 2015.

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End — St. Patrick's Cathedral
Photo: Wikimedia / Sebring12Hrs
#10

#11 Radio City Music Hall

Rockefeller Center executives announced in January 1978 that Radio City Music Hall would shut down because it was losing more than $2 million a year. Public protests and New York City interior landmark designation in March 1978 saved the 5,960-seat auditorium from demolition.

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End — Radio City Music Hall
Photo: Wikimedia / Luca Bravo lucabravo
#11

#10 Carnegie Hall

By 1959, developers planned to raze the 1891 concert hall after the New York Philharmonic announced a move to Lincoln Center. Violinist Isaac Stern rallied musicians and persuaded New York City to buy the building for $5 million in 1960, preserving its main auditorium.

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End — Carnegie Hall
Photo: Wikimedia / Tdorante10
#12

#9 The High Line

Built in 1934 to lift freight trains off Tenth Avenue, the elevated rail line carried its last carload of frozen turkeys in 1980 and grew wild with weeds. Joshua David and Robert Hammond founded Friends of the High Line in 1999, opening the first elevated park section in 2009.

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End — The High Line
Photo: Wikimedia / Crocodiletiger~commonswiki
#13

#8 Times Square

During New York's 1970s fiscal crisis, 42nd Street became synonymous with vacant theaters and street crime, prompting civic leaders to debate wholesale clearance. State and city redevelopment in the 1990s restored historic stages, and pedestrian plazas opened in 2009.

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End — Times Square
Photo: Wikimedia / Terabass
#14

#7 New York Public Library Main Branch

During the 1975 fiscal crisis, New York City cut library budgets so sharply that branches closed days each week and the Fifth Avenue landmark deteriorated. Private philanthropy and major restorations in the 1980s and 2000s revived the Rose Main Reading Room and marble facade.

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End — New York Public Library Main Branch
Photo: Wikimedia / (vincent desjardins) from Paris, France
#15

#6 Central Park

When Frederick Law Olmsted and Calvert Vaux won the park design contest in 1858, critics questioned setting aside 843 acres of prime land. After municipal budget cuts left lawns eroded in the 1970s, the Central Park Conservancy formed in 1980 and restored the grounds.

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End — Central Park
Photo: Wikimedia / Jet Lowe
#16

#5 Ellis Island

Between 1892 and 1954, Ellis Island processed about 12 million immigrants before shutting down and suffering decades of roof leaks and tidal damage. Saved from private redevelopment bids, the Main Building reopened in 1990 after a $156 million federal and private restoration.

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End — Ellis Island
Photo: Wikimedia / David Brossard
#17

#4 Grand Central Terminal

After Penn Station was demolished in 1963, Grand Central faced a similar threat when Penn Central proposed a 55-story tower over its Beaux-Arts concourse in 1968. Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis championed the preservation fight, and the U.S. Supreme Court upheld landmark protection in 1978.

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End — Grand Central Terminal
Photo: Wikimedia / Photograph by Mike Peel ( www.mikepeel.net )
#18

#3 Brooklyn Bridge

Six days after the Brooklyn Bridge opened on May 24, 1883, a rumor that the span was collapsing triggered a deadly stampede on the walkway. To rebuild public trust, showman P.T. Barnum paraded 21 elephants across the East River in May 1884, proving the cables could hold.

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End — Brooklyn Bridge
Photo: Wikimedia / Andrew Choy
#19

#2 Empire State Building

Opened on May 1, 1931 during the Great Depression, the 102-story skyscraper struggled with vacancies for years before becoming profitable in the 1950s. On July 28, 1945, a U.S. Army B-25 bomber struck the fog-shrouded north facade, yet the steel frame held firm.

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End — Empire State Building
Photo: Wikimedia / Dllu
#20

#1 Statue Of Liberty

Dedicated on October 28, 1886 after fundraising stalled for years, the copper statue took shrapnel during the 1916 Black Tom munitions blast in Jersey City. Major restorations in 1986 and after 2012's Hurricane Sandy kept Liberty Island open as a lasting emblem of New York.

20 New York Landmarks That Survived Predictions of the City's End — Statue Of Liberty
Photo: Wikimedia / William Warby

More galleries

Up Next · Recommended Stories

6 stories